Byrd Study
In 1988, Randolph Byrd, M.D., a
cardiologist, tested intercessory prayer over a 10-month
period for 393 patients admitted to a coronary care unit (CCU) in San Francisco. In the randomized, double-blind
study, some differences were noted in the group that had
received prayer by intercession. Among them, patients
were (I) five times less likely to require antibiotics
and (2) three times less likely to develop pulmonary
edema; in addition, (3) none required intubation.
Walker Study
Scott Walker, M.D., a research and treatment
psychiatrist at the Center on Alcohol Substance Abuse and
Addictions, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque,
modeled a study of alcoholics in treatment on the Byrd
study. This two-group, double-blinded study was set up to
evaluate whether patients receiving prayer by
intercession would be more likely to succeed in their
treatment programs. The results, which were made
available in June 1996, showed no statistical difference
between groups. Researchers are still analyzing details
of the study to determine whether they overlooked
something in design or analysis. Some suggest that in a
study such as this, where the illness may be regarded in
an unfavorable or negative light by those interceding,
the effects of prayer may be minimal or nonexistent.
Thurman Study
Ken Thurman, Ph.D., professor of special education
and adjunct professor of pediatrics, at Temple University
in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, is beginning a study that
will examine the role of prayer on the recovery of
premature babies. This study should add some new
information to the growing body of scientific literature
on prayer. In considering the work of previous
researchers, Dr. Thurman, who is a special educator by
training who has worked for the last 20 years on early
intervention with children and families, has created a
double-blinded study that will consider the amount of
prayer received by and its effect on individual babies.
In this study, there will be three groups of babies born
at 30 weeks gestation or less who have no genetic
anomalies. Group I will be the "nonprayer"
group; group II will have two groups praying for it;
group III will have five groups praying for it All parent
participants will be asked to fill out a questionnaire
designed to determine what kind of social support the
family has, their degree of dispositional optimism, and
their level of religiosity. These factors will be
considered when the final results are tabulated. In
addition, parents will be asked to estimate how much
prayer was done by them or other friends and family
during their baby's hospitalization.
|